
By Elsie Nakhle and Mahé Vidot, analysts at Zenon Research
Under the Regulation on the Governance of the Energy Union and Climate Action, France, like all EU member states, has committed to an ambitious energy transition, formalized in its 2021-2030 National Energy and Climate Plan (NECP). This plan, designed to align French energy and climate policies with European Union objectives, aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, expand renewable energy, and improve energy efficiency.
The NECP is structured around the five key dimensions of the Energy Union: decarbonization, energy efficiency, energy security, internal energy market integration, and research, innovation, and competitiveness. It is based on national strategic frameworks such as the Multiannual Energy Program (PPE) and the National Low-Carbon Strategy (SNBC). However, despite ambitious goals, a persistent gap between French ambitions and European requirements raises questions regarding the effectiveness and coherence of the national strategy. Following revisions to its plan by the European Commission, here are the commitments made by France regarding the 5 pillars in the final version of its NECP published in June 2024:

However, despite these well-defined commitments, the French NECP is not without its critics. Some observers, including the European Commission, have expressed concerns regarding the gap between national targets and European ambitions.
France's goal of reaching 33% renewable energy in gross final energy consumption by 2030 is lower than the European target of 42%. This difference highlights France's choice to maintain a significant share of nuclear power in its energy mix—a source considered carbon-free but which does not align with the energy diversification objective advocated by the European Union. In 2023, the share of renewable energy in France reached 22.2%, a figure that is increasing but still falls short of European expectations.
France's nuclear strategy, while reducing carbon emissions, is perceived by the Commission as a barrier to the energy diversification desired by the EU. With 9.9 GW of new nuclear capacity planned by 2026, France is reinforcing the central role of nuclear power, which could limit investment in renewable energies such as wind and solar. According to the European Commission, this could jeopardize the European target of 42.5% renewables by 2030 and hinder the transition toward more flexible and decentralized energy sources. France's target for reducing GHG emissions, recently readjusted to 50% by 2030, remains problematic due to a lack of concrete measures. The adjustments made by France appear timid and risk being insufficient to close the gap with European targets. France will need to reduce its emissions by 5% per year between 2023 and 2030, a major challenge compared to the average annual reduction of 2% achieved between 2017 and 2022.

However, the carbon budgets established by the NECP for this period, at 359 Mt CO2eq per year until 2028, show a reduction trajectory slightly below the -5% annual target, with an annual average closer to 4%. This underperformance risks compromising the achievement of the 2030 goals unless additional and more aggressive measures are implemented to intensify efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

